EdTech Tracker

Ideas

Each idea is scored against everything collected so far, and against new articles as they arrive.

Sign in to add an idea

Restricting students' screen time and phone access in school improves learning and wellbeing.

manual Importance 76% · Attention 4% · Momentum +3%

In favor

These restrictions are more than reasonable in response to serious concerns about the impacts of digital technologies on children.

Opposed

We may just be taking a tool away from our students instead of using it to help them connect with the broader world around them.

Increasingly, it will matter whether you take responsibility for the work, not whether you created it.

manual Importance 70% · Attention 21% · Momentum -24%

In favor

This only gets more true as powerful models like Fable and GPT-5.6 become available.

Opposed

There is no speaker behind the screen, hence no one to refer to, no one to hold responsible.

Some people will be able to produce more interesting things with AI, and that will still require education and training.

manual Importance 72% · Attention 17% · Momentum -17%

In favor

By treating Gemini as a brainstorming partner, my students are learning that technology works best when human creativity leads the way.

Opposed

Nope, they were just given GPT-4 with minimal training and examples.

Restricting access to AI is at best a temporary strategy, not a long-term one.

manual Importance 76% · Attention 13% · Momentum -10%

In favor

Using just the open source models available today, clever developers can continue to fine tune them to produce very effective AIs that can help with many specialized tasks that used to require complex programs.

Opposed

Two years ago the world was just fine without AI sucked less than today, so there's no reason to allow it without fully understanding the consequences.

Standard chat is not going to be a good teaching or tutoring tool; we need to build these.

manual Importance 62% · Attention 14% · Momentum -16%

In favor

Without a purpose-built learning experience, trust often becomes the barrier to enabling AI for students at all.

Opposed

New research shows Americans send nearly 3 million daily messages to ChatGPT asking about compensation and earnings, helping close the wage information gap.

Teaching and auto-grading are far more difficult tasks than the general public or the tech industry understands.

manual Importance 69% · Attention 10% · Momentum -3%

In favor

That gap is what ThinkingBox measures.

Opposed

Viable uses GPT-4 to analyze qualitative data at a revolutionary scale with unparalleled accuracy.

Everyone worries about other industries being replaced by AI, but people who know a domain are less worried.

manual Importance 63% · Attention 9% · Momentum -25%

In favor

At my last talk to prospective students at UNSW Engineering, I told them that engineering is the safest of all jobs against AI displacement because we've always spent our entire careers trying to automate our own workflows. 100% agree with this post.

Opposed

But a new program launched in Utah is raising questions over that assumption.

Critical thinking, curiosity, resilience and other old ideas are now more important, not less.

manual Importance 78% · Attention 24% · Momentum -11%

In favor

And within the AI group, the strong results came from those who asked conceptual questions and requested explanations rather than treating the model as a code vending machine.

Opposed

My take is that cognitive work will diminish.

Prompt engineering will no longer be a useful skill as AI gets smarter. What persists is the ability to define your context, declare your intent and correct the output towards quality.

manual Importance 55% · Attention 6% · Momentum -12%

In favor

You Can't Prompt What You Can't Define

Opposed

But they require experimentation to get right. - Prompting matters a lot: Prompts can make huge differences in outcomes, even if we don’t always know in advance about which prompt will work best.