EdTech Tracker

Restricting students' screen time and phone access in school improves learning and wellbeing.

Idea 1 · manual · Plan

Attention, last 4 weeks
4%
share of items engaging the idea
Momentum
+2%
vs the 4 weeks before
Importance
76%
rated by Jev
Items scored
7997

How it relates

See how it has spread across media tiers

Most alike: #8, #5, #3. See the map.

In tension with #8 (tension and evidence split, open).

In tension with #3 (tension and evidence split, open).

In tension with #4 (tension and evidence split, open).

In tension with #2 (evidence split, open).

In tension with #7 (evidence split, open).

Support and opposition over time

Share of each week's items (by publish date, weighted by source) that support or oppose the idea. Unrelated items dilute both lines.
SupportsOpposes
0.0%25%50%2015-W492022-W512026-W49SupportsOpposes
Table view
WeekItemsSupportsOpposes
2015-W4910.0%0.0%
2016-W0810.0%0.0%
2016-W1710.0%0.0%
2016-W2120.0%0.0%
2016-W2410.0%0.0%
2016-W2520.0%0.0%
2016-W3310.0%0.0%
2016-W3510.0%0.0%
2016-W4120.0%0.0%
2016-W4210.0%0.0%
2016-W4410.0%0.0%
2016-W4530.0%0.0%
2016-W4630.0%0.0%
2016-W4910.0%0.0%
2016-W5110.0%0.0%
2017-W0310.0%0.0%
2017-W0510.0%0.0%
2017-W0610.0%0.0%
2017-W0810.0%0.0%
2017-W1020.0%0.0%
2017-W1120.0%0.0%
2017-W1230.0%0.0%
2017-W1310.0%0.0%
2017-W1410.0%0.0%
2017-W1510.0%0.0%
2017-W1610.0%0.0%
2017-W2020.0%0.0%
2017-W2110.0%0.0%
2017-W2320.0%0.0%
2017-W2410.0%0.0%
2017-W2620.0%0.0%
2017-W2710.0%0.0%
2017-W2920.0%0.0%
2017-W3010.0%0.0%
2017-W3110.0%0.0%
2017-W3210.0%0.0%
2017-W3320.0%0.0%
2017-W3720.0%0.0%
2017-W3910.0%0.0%
2017-W4120.0%0.0%
2017-W4240.0%0.0%
2017-W4310.0%0.0%
2017-W4410.0%0.0%
2017-W4920.0%0.0%
2018-W0310.0%0.0%
2018-W0510.0%0.0%
2018-W0610.0%0.0%
2018-W0710.0%0.0%
2018-W0830.0%0.0%
2018-W0930.0%0.0%
2018-W1030.0%0.0%
2018-W1120.0%0.0%
2018-W1210.0%0.0%
2018-W1410.0%0.0%
2018-W1510.0%0.0%
2018-W1610.0%0.0%
2018-W1810.0%0.0%
2018-W2010.0%0.0%
2018-W2110.0%0.0%
2018-W2220.0%1.0%
2018-W2420.0%0.0%
2018-W2510.0%0.0%
2018-W2610.0%0.0%
2018-W2710.0%0.0%
2018-W2810.0%0.0%
2018-W2910.0%0.0%
2018-W3020.0%0.0%
2018-W3110.0%0.0%
2018-W3210.0%0.0%
2018-W3310.0%0.0%
2018-W3410.0%0.0%
2018-W3710.0%0.0%
2018-W4010.0%0.0%
2018-W4120.0%0.0%
2018-W4310.0%0.0%
2018-W4410.0%0.0%
2018-W4533.2%0.5%
2018-W4910.0%0.0%
2018-W5010.0%0.0%
2018-W5110.0%0.0%
2019-W0510.0%0.0%
2019-W0610.0%0.0%
2019-W0710.0%0.0%
2019-W0810.0%0.0%
2019-W0920.0%0.0%
2019-W1020.0%0.0%
2019-W1110.0%0.0%
2019-W1210.0%0.0%
2019-W1510.0%0.0%
2019-W1620.0%0.0%
2019-W1710.0%0.0%
2019-W1910.0%0.0%
2019-W2010.0%0.0%
2019-W2210.0%0.0%
2019-W2710.0%0.0%
2019-W2910.0%0.0%
2019-W3011.0%0.0%
2019-W3320.0%0.0%
2019-W3720.0%0.0%
2019-W4010.0%0.0%
2019-W4110.0%0.0%
2019-W4410.0%0.0%
2019-W4620.0%0.0%
2019-W4820.0%0.0%
2019-W4910.0%0.0%
2020-W0310.0%0.0%
2020-W0410.0%0.0%
2020-W0610.0%0.0%
2020-W0810.0%0.0%
2020-W1520.0%0.0%
2020-W1710.0%0.0%
2020-W1810.0%0.0%
2020-W2110.0%0.0%
2020-W2310.0%0.0%
2020-W2420.0%0.0%
2020-W2610.0%0.0%
2020-W2710.0%0.0%
2020-W3510.0%0.0%
2020-W3620.0%0.0%
2020-W3810.0%0.0%
2020-W4010.0%0.0%
2020-W4420.0%0.0%
2020-W4510.0%0.0%
2020-W5210.0%0.0%
2021-W0120.0%0.0%
2021-W0320.0%0.0%
2021-W0420.0%0.0%
2021-W0510.0%0.0%
2021-W0620.0%0.0%
2021-W0810.0%0.0%
2021-W0910.0%0.0%
2021-W1020.0%0.0%
2021-W1110.0%0.0%
2021-W1220.0%0.0%
2021-W1310.0%0.0%
2021-W1410.0%0.0%
2021-W1510.0%0.0%
2021-W1610.0%0.0%
2021-W1810.0%0.0%
2021-W1910.0%0.0%
2021-W2110.0%0.0%
2021-W2210.0%0.0%
2021-W2310.0%0.0%
2021-W2610.0%0.0%
2021-W2720.0%0.0%
2021-W2820.0%0.0%
2021-W3010.0%0.0%
2021-W3210.0%0.0%
2021-W3620.0%0.0%
2021-W3720.0%0.0%
2021-W3820.0%0.0%
2021-W4020.0%0.0%
2021-W4110.0%0.0%
2021-W4210.0%0.0%
2021-W4340.0%0.0%
2021-W4410.0%0.0%
2021-W4630.0%0.0%
2021-W4840.0%0.0%
2021-W4910.0%0.0%
2021-W5030.0%0.0%
2021-W5120.0%0.0%
2022-W0230.0%0.0%
2022-W0310.0%0.0%
2022-W0440.0%0.0%
2022-W0530.0%0.0%
2022-W0610.0%0.0%
2022-W0940.0%0.0%
2022-W1010.0%0.0%
2022-W1140.0%0.0%
2022-W1220.0%0.0%
2022-W1310.0%0.0%
2022-W1410.0%0.0%
2022-W1540.0%0.2%
2022-W1770.0%0.2%
2022-W1840.0%0.0%
2022-W1940.0%0.0%
2022-W2070.0%0.0%
2022-W2160.0%0.0%
2022-W22227.7%1.5%
2022-W2330.0%0.0%
2022-W2440.0%0.0%
2022-W2530.0%0.0%
2022-W2650.1%0.0%
2022-W2710.0%0.0%
2022-W2850.0%0.0%
2022-W2930.0%0.0%
2022-W3050.0%0.0%
2022-W3140.0%0.0%
2022-W3250.0%0.0%
2022-W3340.5%0.0%
2022-W3440.0%0.0%
2022-W3520.0%0.0%
2022-W3620.0%0.0%
2022-W3720.0%0.0%
2022-W3820.0%0.0%
2022-W3940.0%0.0%
2022-W4030.0%0.0%
2022-W4130.0%0.0%
2022-W4230.0%0.0%
2022-W4310.0%0.0%
2022-W4430.0%0.0%
2022-W4530.0%0.0%
2022-W4630.0%0.0%
2022-W4740.0%0.0%
2022-W48190.5%0.2%
2022-W4960.0%0.6%
2022-W50100.0%0.3%
2022-W5150.0%0.3%
2023-W0010.0%0.0%
2023-W0170.0%26.5%
2023-W0240.4%0.8%
2023-W0360.0%5.3%
2023-W0470.0%10.6%
2023-W0560.0%0.0%
2023-W0670.0%0.0%
2023-W0760.0%14.3%
2023-W0860.0%0.0%
2023-W0960.0%0.1%
2023-W1040.0%0.0%
2023-W11100.0%3.5%
2023-W1260.0%0.3%
2023-W13100.0%0.0%
2023-W1450.0%0.5%
2023-W1530.0%0.0%
2023-W1630.0%6.1%
2023-W1760.0%0.0%
2023-W1830.0%0.0%
2023-W1960.0%0.6%
2023-W2070.0%0.1%
2023-W2190.0%0.0%
2023-W2270.0%0.4%
2023-W2330.0%0.0%
2023-W2490.0%1.0%
2023-W2550.0%0.0%
2023-W2650.6%3.8%
2023-W2760.0%0.0%
2023-W2820.0%0.0%
2023-W2990.3%8.8%
2023-W3040.0%0.0%
2023-W3180.0%0.0%
2023-W3260.0%0.0%
2023-W3340.4%0.0%
2023-W3470.0%0.0%
2023-W3540.0%1.6%
2023-W3640.0%0.0%
2023-W3770.0%0.0%
2023-W3850.0%0.0%
2023-W3960.0%0.0%
2023-W4060.0%0.0%
2023-W4140.0%0.0%
2023-W4230.0%0.0%
2023-W4370.0%0.0%
2023-W4420.0%0.8%
2023-W4580.0%0.0%
2023-W4610.0%0.0%
2023-W4710.0%0.0%
2023-W4830.0%0.0%
2023-W4950.0%0.0%
2023-W5070.0%0.0%
2023-W5130.0%4.4%
2024-W0140.0%0.0%
2024-W0270.0%0.0%
2024-W0370.0%0.0%
2024-W0440.0%0.0%
2024-W05100.0%0.9%
2024-W0620.0%0.0%
2024-W0750.0%0.0%
2024-W0870.0%0.0%
2024-W0940.0%0.0%
2024-W1090.0%0.0%
2024-W1150.0%0.0%
2024-W12130.0%0.1%
2024-W1360.0%0.0%
2024-W1490.0%0.2%
2024-W1560.0%0.0%
2024-W1680.0%0.0%
2024-W1780.2%2.1%
2024-W18120.0%0.0%
2024-W1970.0%0.0%
2024-W20140.0%0.1%
2024-W21100.0%0.0%
2024-W22100.0%0.4%
2024-W2370.0%0.0%
2024-W2470.0%0.1%
2024-W25120.0%2.7%
2024-W2660.0%0.0%
2024-W2730.0%0.0%
2024-W2880.0%0.0%
2024-W2970.1%0.0%
2024-W3060.0%0.0%
2024-W3140.0%0.0%
2024-W3290.0%0.2%
2024-W3380.0%0.0%
2024-W3460.0%0.0%
2024-W3550.0%9.0%
2024-W3630.0%0.0%
2024-W37110.0%0.2%
2024-W3890.0%0.1%
2024-W3960.0%0.0%
2024-W40250.3%0.2%
2024-W4170.0%0.0%
2024-W4240.0%0.0%
2024-W43130.0%0.0%
2024-W4470.0%0.3%
2024-W4530.0%0.0%
2024-W4630.0%0.0%
2024-W4790.0%0.3%
2024-W4830.0%0.0%
2024-W4990.0%1.1%
2024-W50110.0%0.0%
2024-W51100.0%0.0%
2024-W5230.0%0.0%
2024-W5310.0%0.0%
2025-W0130.0%0.0%
2025-W0260.0%0.0%
2025-W03120.0%0.1%
2025-W04200.2%0.1%
2025-W05100.0%6.0%
2025-W06130.0%0.0%
2025-W0770.3%0.0%
2025-W08100.0%0.0%
2025-W0980.0%0.4%
2025-W1080.0%0.5%
2025-W11110.0%0.0%
2025-W12140.1%0.9%
2025-W1390.0%0.0%
2025-W14150.0%0.2%
2025-W15120.0%0.0%
2025-W1690.0%0.2%
2025-W1770.0%0.0%
2025-W18150.0%0.1%
2025-W19100.0%0.0%
2025-W20140.0%0.0%
2025-W21130.1%0.0%
2025-W2280.0%0.0%
2025-W2370.0%0.0%
2025-W2450.0%0.0%
2025-W2560.0%0.0%
2025-W2650.0%0.9%
2025-W27143.9%2.8%
2025-W28130.0%0.0%
2025-W29130.0%0.8%
2025-W3080.4%1.6%
2025-W31250.3%0.2%
2025-W3280.1%0.0%
2025-W33110.0%0.0%
2025-W3480.0%0.1%
2025-W3583.1%5.5%
2025-W36140.8%0.0%
2025-W37122.4%1.0%
2025-W38160.2%0.5%
2025-W39280.4%0.0%
2025-W40150.0%0.0%
2025-W41110.1%0.0%
2025-W42240.8%0.2%
2025-W43300.2%0.1%
2025-W44160.1%0.2%
2025-W45220.0%0.3%
2025-W46340.0%0.2%
2025-W47190.1%4.1%
2025-W48200.0%0.0%
2025-W49300.0%0.7%
2025-W50260.4%0.2%
2025-W51120.0%0.0%
2025-W5260.0%0.0%
2026-W0030.0%0.0%
2026-W01130.3%0.0%
2026-W02190.2%17.6%
2026-W03231.1%0.2%
2026-W04310.3%0.7%
2026-W05190.2%0.2%
2026-W06220.0%0.1%
2026-W07170.1%0.1%
2026-W08180.4%0.0%
2026-W09270.0%0.4%
2026-W10220.1%1.1%
2026-W11190.6%0.1%
2026-W12270.1%0.0%
2026-W13200.2%0.2%
2026-W14400.1%0.3%
2026-W15200.0%0.0%
2026-W16270.0%0.2%
2026-W17261.0%0.9%
2026-W18310.1%0.3%
2026-W19460.8%1.9%
2026-W20340.1%1.3%
2026-W21300.5%0.1%
2026-W22430.2%0.0%
2026-W23390.1%8.1%
2026-W24250.0%0.2%
2026-W25360.0%0.2%
2026-W26230.3%1.0%
2026-W27400.0%0.0%
2026-W28382.7%1.8%
2026-W29312.3%0.7%
2026-W30390.5%1.6%
2026-W31440.1%0.9%
2026-W32460.0%0.5%
2026-W33420.2%5.4%
2026-W34500.8%2.7%
2026-W35720.4%1.3%
2026-W36723.2%6.3%
2026-W37772.4%2.9%
2026-W381241.5%1.3%
2026-W392672.2%1.1%
2026-W409601.1%2.8%
2026-W411730.7%0.4%
2026-W42620.8%2.8%
2026-W43790.5%2.5%
2026-W441221.4%1.2%
2026-W451432.1%1.0%
2026-W464022.6%0.8%
2026-W4810.0%0.0%
2026-W4920.7%0.0%

In their words

Verbatim quotes from the strongest supporting and opposing articles. Feeds carry little text, so most are a headline or a short excerpt.

In favor

These restrictions are more than reasonable in response to serious concerns about the impacts of digital technologies on children.

A nationwide study shows learning gains, which makes sense.

Then you got into The Coddling of the American Mind , and then you wrote The Anxious Generation about phones, which not only changed America—I go to schools all the time with no phones in them, and the kids love them, without exception—it also sold a zillion copies.

Opposed

We may just be taking a tool away from our students instead of using it to help them connect with the broader world around them.

I use technology to give students a voice and become critical digital citizens.

For the last few years the thing moving fastest has been generative AI, and readers of this blog know that I have no faith in either of the standard institutional responses, prohibition or wholesale uncritical adoption.

Predictions on this idea

No predictions yet.